Best Pizza Pans of 2021: Our Top Picks

By Kitchen Warrior | Pizza Tools & Cookware Guides

Best Pizza Pans - thekitchenwarriors.com
Spread the love

To make the perfect pizza at home, no matter what size, you need to have the right pan at your disposal. Finding one is not that easy, so we looked for a few of them to make your homemade pizza much easier to make.

We will take a look at the great features included with these best pizza pans that set them apart from the rest. To find out what makes them different, read with us about those we found and what they have to offer the home pizza maker.

Comparison Chart

Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Pizza Pan

LloydPans Detroit Style Pizza Pan

Wilton Pizza Pan

LloydPans re-Seasoned Sicilian Pizza Pan

Wilton Crisper Pizza Pan

Best Pizza Pans Reviews

Cuisinart Chef's Classic Pizza Pan

You can not go wrong when you choose this pizza pan to make your homemade pizza the best way you can. This pan from Cuisinart is very reliable and made durable to last for many hours of happy pizza baking at home.

Review

This pizza pan from Cuisinart is the perfect size at 14 inches to fit your standard size homemade pizza in. You have the right measurements for your pizza right in front of you when you want to cut the dough to the right size.

With the perforation of the surface of this pizza pan, you can bake a nice crispy pizza without the worry that it will burn. So your pizza will be evenly baked all over with direct heat entering from the bottom to make sure it is done.

The pan is made from heavy-duty aluminized steel materials that will evenly distribute the heat. This also contributes to a strong and durable pizza pan that will last for a very long time for many hours of baking.

The thick rolled edges this pizza pan is made with will help prevent the pan’s warping at high heat. The heavy gauge material of 1 millimeter will also help to make it even more durable, to provide you with consistent baking results.

For easy cleaning purposes, the pan can be safely washed in the dishwasher to save you a lot of time and effort. On top of that, it also comes with a lifetime warranty included, backing their claim of long-lasting quality.

Even though they say that the pan comes with a non-stick feature, some people experienced their pizza sticking. So it is much safer to use a little bit of oil or spray-on so it will not ruin your pizza pan.

Some people also find the holes on the surface of the pan to be a bit too large for their liking.

PROS

  • Made with a very durable construction
  • High-quality materials used
  • It comes with a lifetime warranty
  • The pan is very easy to clean after use

CONS

  • Some may find the holes to be too large
  • Not a perfect non-stick option

LloydPans Kitchenware Detroit Style Pizza Pan

With the heavy-duty rugged construction of this pizza pan, you can keep on using it for many years to come. This pizza pan is the ideal tool to use for all that pizza family night for a fun time around the table.

Review

With the very large interior cooking space of this pan, you can make quite a large pizza to feed the whole family. This is the ideal pizza pan if you love your Detroit style pizza and you will have a lot of it to satisfy the craving.

The stick-resistant coating that is applied to this pan will help you to make the perfect pizza every time you use it. To top that, the coating that makes it stick-resistant is PTFE free to make it safe to use with your food.

A great thing about this pizza pan is that it is ready to use when you receive it; there is no pre-seasoning needed. That means you can buy the pan and start mixing your dough even on the first day you receive it.

The pan is made from very high-quality hard anodized-aluminum materials to make it very strong and durable to last for a very long time. So this means the pan for your pizzas will be with you long enough to enjoy many hours of happy pizza baking.

It is quite easy to clean this pan after use because there will be no burned food stuck to the pan. Just an easy wipe to clean it, and it is also heat-resistant to up to 700 degrees Fahrenheit.

But knowing this pan may last for a long time, you still need to have a backup warranty from the manufacturer. Unfortunately, you will not get a decent warranty with this pan, which doesn’t really bode well for how they feel about their product.

The coating that improves the durability of the pan may chip and take away some of the value of the pan.

PROS

  • Has a large interior cooking space
  • Made very durable and strong
  • It comes with a high heat resistance
  • The pizza slides out quite easy

CONS

  • It does not come with a decent warranty
  • The coating may chip at some point

Wilton Premium Pizza Pan

The promise of perfect results every time you use this pizza pan for baking your pizza should be enough to try it out. This seems like a decent pan with all the right features to provide you with your personal favorite food.

Review

You will be able to easily clean this pizza pan with only warm soapy water and a cloth to save you time. To make it even better, it is also safe to wash this pan in the dishwasher if you are an on the go person.

For that perfect standard size homemade pizza, the 14 inches size of this pan is just the right size for lunch. When you are done baking your pizza, you will be proud that you can make it just like the ones you order.

You can use this same pan for baking anything else in the oven as well. This makes the pan quite versatile, and you will be happy to know it is still there for your pizza baking.

This pizza pan provided by Wilton is made from very durable steel that will make it last for a very long time. Also included with the pan is a non-stick feature to help you have a perfect bake every time you use it.

Because of the very durable construction, you will be able to have many hours of pizza baking as well as other nice food. To back the quality construction of this pan, the manufacturer provides a 5-year limited warranty with it.

There are, unfortunately, no holes in the surface of the pan to add to the overall cooking quality. It also means that you will not have that benefit at your disposal to secure a crispy, evenly baked pizza every time.

You should not use hard metal utensils on this pan because it may scratch the surface and ruin the non-stick capability.

PROS

  • This pizza pan is dishwasher safe
  • Ideal for you standard homemade pizza
  • Can be used for a wide variety of options
  • Comes with a 5-year limited warranty

CONS

  • You have no holes in the surface
  • Pan may scratch easily with utensils

LloydPan Pre-Seasoned Sicilian Pizza Pan

This very large, durable pizza pan is ideal for Sicilian style pizza to feed your family and friends. This is a great pizza pan for getting together with friends and doing what people like to do, to eat nice and tasty food.

Review

With this pizza pan, you can easily put it in a very hot oven of up to 700 degrees Fahrenheit to ensure a well-cooked pizza. The materials used in the construction are highly heat resistant, so it is quite safe to bake at very high temperatures.

For those people who love to make a lot of food at a time, the cooking space of this pan is ideal for that. With the large 14 x 14 inches, it is perfect for cooking that Sicilian pizza to feed everyone in one cooking.

When you are done cooking, you can easily clean this pizza pan, wiping it with only warm soapy water. This will save you time and effort, and it may also help protect your pan to last for a long time.

When it comes to pizza, the chances are that you will not have a need for any other food types to stifle hunger. Sometimes, you need to eat something else, and that is where the pan will help you out.

The pan is quite versatile to be used to cook a wide variety of other food as well, just until the pizza craving comes back. The 14 gauge aluminum materials used with this pan will distribute the heat all over the pan evenly.

Because of the large size of the pizza you will make in this pan, you may sometimes have a problem. The food may not completely cook in the center and cause the food to get stuck in the other parts of the pan.

You should not wash this pan in the dishwasher, which may cause the pan to chip, and rusting may occur.

PROS

  • High-temperature resistance capability
  • Comes with a very large cooking space
  • Very little maintenance required
  • Can be used for many different cooking options

CONS

  • Your food might get stuck in the middle
  • Not to be washed in the dishwasher

Wilton Crisper Pizza Pan

As usual, you will get a high-quality product from this manufacturer that will do what it is intended to do. That intention was always the reason this pan is made, and you will not regret trying it out to make your perfect homemade pizza.

Review

With this pizza pan provided by Milton, you have easy carrying handles included for carrying the hot pan to where you need it. This is great for those people who are always in a hurry and want to grab and go with the pan.

It comes included with very small holes to provide you with easy airflow for even cooking of the crust. It will also help you to prevent making a mess, so the crumbs will not fall through the holes when cutting the pizza.

The round shape of the pan is a perfect size and shape for your homemade pizzas. The pan itself can be used when you need to cut your base to the perfect size when preparing the crust.

For keeping your pizza pan clean, this pan is safe to be used with the dishwasher to save you time and effort. Or you can just wipe it clean in warm soapy water to be ready for the next pizza baking episode.

It is made from very high-quality materials to help it last for many years of perfect homemade pizza baking. It also comes with a non-stick option to help you have a perfect pizza every time you bake one at home.

This pan can only be used inside an oven, so you cannot use it on a stovetop, as it may become damaged quite easily. You may not think it is such an issue, but sometimes people would love to make their food on a gas burner.

It also does not have that many holes so it isn't quite the perfect pan for crispy pizza.

PROS

  • There are carry handles included
  • Very small holes for perfect airflow
  • Provides you with a crispy pizza
  • Comes with a long 10-year limited warranty

CONS

  • Can only be used inside an oven

FINAL VERDICT

From a line of very useful and high-quality pizza pans, we chose the Cuisinart Chef’s Classic pizza pan as the number 1. It comes with high-durability and great features that will help you make the perfect pizza at home every time.

In the number 2 spot, we have the Wilton 14 inches Crisper pizza pan with the same great features included. It also comes with a slightly lower price point attached to it to make it affordable for many more people out there.